Theos-Talk Archives (September 2002 Message tt00133)

Dear Brian/Brigitte, 

You wrote:

"So far no single historian has chalenged the information on my web 
site."

Is this true?

Let us take but one example. There are a number of webpages on 
your site apparently written by Peter Washington. I 
wonder if Washington knows that his material has been copied/ 
published on this site. Anyway... many of Washington's comments 
about HPB have already been challenged by W. T. S. Thackara in his 
article "Notes on Madame Blavatsky's Baboon." See
http://home.pacbell.net/amsec/theo2b.html
This article first appeared in THEOSOPHICAL HISTORY edited by Dr. 
James Santucci.

Brian/Brigitte, you also wrote:

"Also Daniel Caldwell does not answer with valid historical 
counterarguments adressing any of the issues, instead he does 
everything to distract from the issues at hand."

Concerning your [Brian's/Brigitte's] various postings on Theos-Talk I 
have brought up a number of valid historical counterarguments over 
many months. Usually you just ignore them. 

OBTW, Wes Amerman, to mention but one other person, has answered many 
of your arguments but you usually just ignore Wes' excellent points.

Also read what Wes writes about you:

"Dear Brian, You've managed to bring up all sorts of irrelevant 
things without hardly addressing the issues at all...."

"In previous posts, I and others have put forward several essential 
issues between Theosophy and Science. But, you are going to have to 
address those before I go much further in this discussion." 

And to end my posting, when you write about "a brilliant observation 
by Steve", I must say that although I do not agree with many of 
Steve's observations, I do agree that from time to time Steve can 
come up with a "brilliant observation" such as the following:

"I think most of us know that Brian and Brigitte are the same soul. 
The truth is that she acknowledged this several months ago on another 
list. Her games amuse me. It is equally amusing to see so many of us 
feeding her enormous appetite with fleshy ego-bits of our own."

Daniel