Theos-Talk Archives (October 2008 Message tt00286)

Anand,

You say Blavatsky was ordered to mislead people.

And then you quote this letter from the Master:

------------------------------------------------------------
The Old Woman is accused of untruthfulness, inaccuracy in her
statements. "Ask no questions and you will receive no lies." She is
forbidden to say what she knows. You may cut her to pieces and she
will not tell. Nay -- she is ordered in cases of need to mislead
people; and, were she more of a natural born liar -- she might be
happier and won her day long since by this time. 
-----------------------------------------------------------

Quoted from:
http://www.theosociety.org/pasadena/mahatma/ml-47.htm

Now let me see if I understand what you are trying to tell
us here.

You say Blavatsky was ordered by the Master to mislead people.

But Anand how do YOU KNOW that this quote is really from one of the
Masters?

According to your own previous speculation, you write that
many of the letters supposedly from the Masters are actually
simply "carrying thoughts of Blavatsky PRETENDING to be thoughts of 
Masters."

So this Letter #47 may just be "carrying thoughts of Blavatsky 
PRETENDING to be thoughts of Masters."

In other words, this letter, this quote is NOT from the Master....

Anand, how do YOU REALLY KNOW one way or the other???

Tell us how you have determined that this is really from the Master?

How did you determine it??  

I would love to sit down with you in your house and go thru the book 
THE MAHATMA LETTERS TO A.P. SINNETT and let you tell me if Letter No 
1 is from the Master or not and your reasons for accepting it or 
rejecting it, and go thru all of the letters one by one, etc. etc. 

In this process I might actually discover your reasoning and thinking 
on all of this which up to this point is not at all clear to me!!!!!

But even if this letter conveys the Master's real thought, what is 
the Master actually referring to in the quote given by you?????

Anand, are you suggesting to us that the Master ordered Blavatsky to 
mislead people about the real teachings of Theosophy?????

Are you telling us that H.P. Blavatsky was under orders from the 
Masters to mislead readers about THE TEACHINGS of Theosophy when she 
wrote ISIS UNVEILED, THE SECRET DOCTRINE, THE KEY TO THEOSOPHY, THE 
VOICE OF THE SILENCE and her 1000 articles??????

Please Anand tell us specifically what you are trying to convey to us?

I must honestly admit that I have no clear idea whatsoever as to what 
your thinking on this is all about.....

Daniel
http://hpb.cc