theos-talk.com

[MASTER INDEX] [DATE INDEX] [THREAD INDEX] [SUBJECT INDEX] [AUTHOR INDEX]

[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next]

Publishing on the Internet.

May 19, 2005 04:00 PM
by Jerry Hejka-Ekins


Dear Ramadoss, friends,

I have many times seen your message advocating that instead of paper and ink publishing, everything should be instead published on the Internet. I have been giving this matter considerable thought and I agree with many of the ideals behind this notion, such as:

1. Making literature available to those who cannot afford it

2. A potentially larger reading audience (maybe).

3.It would not cost the reader anything to access the information.
However, there are other issues which I have not seen you address, and would appreciate it if you and/or others would address them:

1. Reciprosity: There is a prevailing attitude, at least in Western cultures, that if something is free, it must not have any value. I have experimented with this and am convinced that this is basically true. When I started an experimental journal, I began by giving away copies at gatherings etc. in the hopes of gaining subscribers. No one subscribed. I changed my tactic and started putting out "Display copies" of the journal for people to look at, people began pulling out their check books.

2. Compensation for labor: Whether it be the production of a Journal, or the compilation of a book like the Blavatsky collected letters, there is involved hundreds, and sometimes thousands of hours of combined labor to put the work into a publishable form. For instance, in the case of the Blavatsky letters, in order for the letters to have been correctly prepared for publication, time was required to access the letters, transcribe them, check them for accuracy, research the historical background of each letter, and to compose the needed background information.
3. Compensation for actual costs: Even a not-for-profit organization has costs. If a book is to be published in the traditional way, one must sell the book at a price which will recover the printing and labor costs, plus a little more so that there will be money to finance the next project. If the work is the be given away over the Internet, there are still costs involved in creating and maintaining of the website.

4. Intellectual property: In the case of the publication of original information, one may spend years years researching a subject, and thousands of dollars in incidental expences involved in getting this information. If the information is freely published on the Internet for anyone to use, how with the researcher recover his/her expences and time invested which could have been used to make money for other charitable projects? Further, going back to the reciprosity argument, would the information be as valued and as appreciated it it was available at no cost?
One more comment: I have been googling all over the Internet for some years now and have been quite amazed at the amount of information (and mis-information) one can find on any subject. Much of this information on the one hand, comes from books which are now in public domain, or on the other, people who like to talk out of their .... I have also seen a lot of student's papers on different subjects. What I rarely (if at all) see, is quality publishible research and other such materials from known scholars in any given field. Brill academic publishers still have no problem selling their original scholarly publications at very hight prices--a thin volume of a hundred pages will sell for over $120.00 a copy. This kind of scholarship does not appear on the Internet.
Jerry






MKR wrote:

Lot of time effort and money can be saved by using Internet. Compile the competing Vol I and upload it to Internet. You will also have much wider and larger audience who will read the material since it would not cost anything for the reader other than time to download. Just a simplistic thought.

mkr

At 12:22 PM 05/19/05 +0000, kpauljohnson wrote:


Hey,

Having just discovered this publication this month, I'm intrigued by
the current cause celebre. Turn to page 21 for information about
an "H.P. Blavatsky Defense Fund" being established in order to
publish a competing Volume I of the Letters of H.P. Blavatsky, the
Adyar version of which ULTers confidently assert contains twenty
forgeries.









[Back to Top]


Theosophy World: Dedicated to the Theosophical Philosophy and its Practical Application